In a situation like this, it's essential to act ethically and honestly. If you notice that you were not charged for one of the items you ate during an excellent meal at a nice restaurant, it is best to inform the server or the restaurant staff about the oversight.
Here's why you should tell the server:
Honesty: Being honest is a fundamental value in any ethical decision-making process. If you knowingly benefit from an error or mistake without rectifying it, you are essentially taking something that doesn't belong to you.
Fairness: Paying for the correct bill ensures fairness to the restaurant and its staff, who work hard to provide excellent service and quality food. It also ensures fairness to other customers who might have to bear the burden of such errors through higher prices or other measures.
Reputation: Acting with integrity and honesty reflects positively on your character. People tend to appreciate and respect those who are honest, even in small matters like this.
Legal implications: In some places, deliberately not reporting errors in bills can be considered as an attempt to defraud, which may have legal consequences.
Restaurant's success: Supporting the restaurant's financial success is essential for its sustainability. By paying the correct bill, you are contributing to its continued operation and success.
If you're unsure about how to address the situation, you can politely bring the error to the server's attention and ask for clarification. They will likely appreciate your honesty, and the restaurant will correct the bill accordingly. It's always better to do the right thing, even if it may be uncomfortable in the moment.