Question

A neighbour just admitted to me she's called social services on our other neighbour for leaving her 12 year old home alone after school while she works until 6pm. Am I wrong for telling her she's out of order?

Answer 1

It's understandable that you may have strong feelings about your neighbor's decision to call social services on another neighbor. Whether or not you think your neighbor's actions are out of order may depend on various factors and your perspective on the situation.

Here are some considerations to keep in mind:

1. Legality and safety: Leaving a 12-year-old child home alone for an extended period, such as until 6 pm, may not be legal or safe in some jurisdictions. Laws regarding the minimum age for leaving children unsupervised vary depending on the country and region. Safety and well-being should be the top priority when discussing such situations.

2. Concern for the child: The neighbor who called social services may genuinely be concerned for the well-being and safety of the 12-year-old child. They might have perceived a potential risk or harm in the child being home alone for extended periods.

3. Communication: It's essential for neighbors to communicate openly and respectfully about concerns they may have for each other's children. Expressing concerns and discussing potential solutions in a non-confrontational manner can be helpful.

4. Social services' role: Social services exist to protect children and ensure their safety. If they become involved, their primary goal is to assess the situation and provide support if needed.

5. Different perspectives: People may have different opinions on what is considered appropriate parenting or child supervision. Cultural, societal, and personal factors can influence these perspectives.

6. Legal obligations: In some places, certain professionals, such as teachers or healthcare workers, may have a legal obligation to report suspected child neglect or abuse.

Ultimately, it's essential to approach such situations with empathy, understanding, and an open mind. Encourage communication and dialogue between neighbors, and consider the best interests of the child involved. If you're concerned about the situation, you could also discuss it with the parent involved or suggest exploring alternative childcare arrangements if possible.