I can provide some insights into the topic.
The effectiveness of disciplining children in front of others, including siblings, is a matter of debate among parenting experts and psychologists. There are various perspectives on this issue:
Privacy and Respect: Some experts argue that disciplining a child in private is essential to preserve the child's dignity and self-esteem. Publicly reprimanding a child can be embarrassing and may lead to resentment, damaged relationships, or even a negative impact on the child's emotional well-being.
Setting Boundaries: On the other hand, some parents and experts believe that discipline should not be hidden from other family members. They argue that witnessing consequences for undesirable behavior can help siblings understand boundaries and appropriate behavior.
Individual Differences: The effectiveness of this approach can vary depending on the child's personality and temperament. Some children may be more sensitive and respond better to private discussions about their behavior, while others might not be as affected by public reprimands.
Positive Discipline: Many modern parenting approaches focus on positive discipline, emphasizing communication, understanding, and teaching appropriate behavior instead of relying solely on punishment. This often involves discussing behaviors privately and providing consistent consequences.
Ultimately, the goal of discipline should be to teach children right from wrong and guide them toward becoming responsible, respectful, and compassionate individuals. Parents should consider their child's emotional needs and temperament, and strive to maintain open communication and mutual respect when addressing behavioral issues.
It's important for parents to find a balance between maintaining discipline and preserving the child's dignity and emotional well-being. Openly discussing family rules, setting clear expectations, and applying consistent consequences can be effective approaches to discipline without resorting to public humiliation or embarrassment.