The decision of whether people who have been sober for years should be kicked out of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) meetings is ultimately up to the guidelines and principles set by the organization itself and the individual groups within it. However, it's essential to consider several factors when discussing this issue.
Tradition and Support: One of the key aspects of AA is its tradition of "one alcoholic helping another." People who have been sober for years can provide valuable support, wisdom, and guidance to those who are still struggling with alcoholism. Their experience can be a source of inspiration and hope for those trying to achieve long-term sobriety.
Maintenance of Sobriety: Remaining engaged with AA meetings and the AA community can help individuals in long-term recovery maintain their sobriety. Being a part of a supportive network can be essential for their continued success in staying sober.
Humility and Gratitude: People who have achieved long-term sobriety through AA often have a sense of humility and gratitude. They understand the importance of giving back to the community and being of service to others who are still struggling with alcoholism.
Inclusivity and Fellowship: AA meetings are designed to be inclusive, and everyone is welcome to attend. The fellowship aspect is essential for creating a supportive environment for individuals at all stages of recovery.
Individual Progress: Recovery is a highly individualized journey, and different people may have different needs at different stages. Some individuals in long-term recovery may still find value in attending AA meetings for personal growth and to remain connected to the recovery community.
If there are specific concerns about the dynamic within a particular AA group or if there are logistical issues regarding space and time, it might be more appropriate to address those concerns directly rather than targeting individuals who have achieved long-term sobriety.
It's also important to remember that AA is just one of many pathways to recovery, and different approaches may work better for different individuals. Ultimately, the primary goal should be to support individuals in their recovery journey, regardless of where they are on that path.