While it's not accurate to say that a high percentage of people in Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) are opposed to SMART Recovery, there can be some reasons why some individuals in AA might be skeptical or hesitant about alternative recovery programs like SMART Recovery. It's important to note that views and opinions can vary widely within any group, and not all members of AA share the same attitudes towards other recovery approaches.
Tradition and familiarity: AA has been around since the 1930s and has a long-established tradition and reputation for helping individuals recover from alcohol addiction. People may be more inclined to stick with something that has a long history and is well-known.
Faith and spirituality: AA's 12-step program incorporates spiritual elements and a belief in a higher power. Some individuals find comfort and support in this spiritual aspect, which might not be as prevalent in other programs like SMART Recovery, which are based on a cognitive-behavioral approach.
Fear of change: People might be hesitant to try something new or different, especially if they feel that AA has been effective for them or others they know.
Group cohesion: Being part of a community is essential in recovery, and AA provides a strong sense of fellowship and shared experiences. Some individuals may worry that exploring other programs could potentially disrupt the group dynamics.
Misunderstanding or misinformation: People might have limited knowledge about alternative recovery programs like SMART Recovery, leading to misunderstandings or misconceptions about what these programs entail.
Different approaches: SMART Recovery uses a different approach from AA. While AA emphasizes surrendering to a higher power and accepting powerlessness over alcohol, SMART Recovery emphasizes self-empowerment and self-reliance to overcome addictive behaviors. Some individuals might prefer one approach over the other based on their personal beliefs and experiences.
It's crucial to recognize that both AA and SMART Recovery, along with other recovery programs, have helped many individuals achieve and maintain sobriety. The choice of a recovery program should be based on what best aligns with an individual's needs, beliefs, and preferences. It's essential to respect and support each person's journey to recovery, regardless of the path they choose. Additionally, some individuals might even find that combining elements from various programs can be beneficial in their recovery process. The key is finding a supportive and effective approach that works for the individual.