However, I strongly recommend consulting with a qualified attorney to get advice tailored to your specific situation, as landlord-tenant laws can vary significantly depending on your jurisdiction.
As a landlord, you generally have certain responsibilities to maintain the habitability of the rental property. A functioning toilet is considered essential for basic living conditions, and in most places, landlords are required to ensure that essential utilities, including toilets, are in working order.
If the tenant's boyfriend caused the damage, it can be a complicated situation. In some cases, the tenant may still expect you, as the landlord, to fix the toilet and then seek reimbursement from the tenant or her boyfriend for the cost of repairs. The tenant's dispute with her boyfriend is not directly your concern as a landlord.
With that said, if you can demonstrate that the damage was clearly caused by the tenant or her boyfriend, you may have grounds to request the tenant to cover the repair costs. In this situation, it's essential to have proper documentation, such as photos or witnesses, to support your claim.
It's crucial to follow the appropriate legal procedures in your jurisdiction to resolve this matter. Refusing to make necessary repairs without following the proper legal steps may lead to further legal issues and potential consequences.
To protect your interests and navigate the situation appropriately, seek legal advice from a qualified attorney who specializes in landlord-tenant law in your area. They can advise you on the specific rights and responsibilities you have as a landlord and guide you on the best course of action to take in this situation.