there isn't a book specifically titled "Makhanlal Saha clinical" that I'm aware of. It's possible that such a book may have been published or gained popularity .
On the other hand, "S. Das Clinical Surgery" is a well-known and widely used textbook in the field of surgery. It is authored by Dr. S. Das and is considered a comprehensive resource for medical students and practitioners studying surgery. The book covers various surgical topics, including principles of surgery, surgical techniques, and common surgical conditions.
Without specific information on the content and quality of "Makhanlal Saha clinical," it is challenging to make a direct comparison. If the book has been released , I recommend checking reviews, ratings, and recommendations from fellow medical students or professionals to gauge its usefulness and relevance for surgical studies.
In any case, when choosing a textbook, it's essential to consider your curriculum, the style of writing that suits your learning, and the specific topics covered in each book. Additionally, consulting with your professors or senior colleagues for their suggestions can also be valuable in making an informed decision.