When your girlfriend asks you, "What did you feel when you first saw me?" the best approach is to be honest and genuine in your response. Share your true feelings, as sincerity and authenticity are essential in any relationship.
If you felt a strong positive emotion like attraction, joy, or excitement when you first saw her, express that. You could say something like, "When I first saw you, I felt an instant connection and a rush of happiness. You caught my attention in a way I can't explain, and I was genuinely excited to get to know you better."
On the other hand, if you were a bit unsure or didn't have strong feelings right from the start, it's okay to share that too. For example, you might say, "When I first saw you, I thought you were interesting and intriguing. As we spent more time together, I realized how amazing and special you are, and my feelings for you grew deeper."
Remember, the key is to be honest while being sensitive to her feelings. Avoid saying something just to please her if it doesn't align with your true emotions. Open communication and genuine feelings are vital for a healthy and successful relationship.