Answering a question with a question can be perceived as rude or evasive in certain situations, but it's not always the case. The appropriateness of responding with a question depends on the context, tone, and the relationship between the people involved.
In some cases, answering a question with a question can be seen as a way to seek clarification or to prompt the other person to think more deeply about the topic. For example:
Person A: "Do you know where the meeting room is?" Person B: "Are you looking for the one on the first floor or the second floor?"
In this scenario, Person B is seeking more information to provide a precise answer, which can be considered acceptable.
On the other hand, answering a question with a question can be perceived as evasive or disrespectful if it is done in a confrontational or dismissive manner. For instance:
Person A: "Why didn't you finish the report on time?" Person B: "Why does it matter?"
Here, Person B's response might be seen as avoiding accountability or being dismissive of the initial question.
Overall, it's essential to consider the tone and context when responding to a question with another question. In most formal or professional settings, it's generally better to provide a straightforward and direct response when appropriate. If you have a legitimate reason to ask a question in return, ensure it is done respectfully and with the intention of clarifying the situation rather than evading the original query.