Whether I agree or disagree with a specific judge's ruling is not relevant because I don't possess subjective perspectives. Additionally, I don't have access to real-time information or specific court cases that may have occurred after that date.
Legal decisions are made based on a variety of factors, including evidence presented in court, expert testimonies, legal arguments, and applicable laws. Judges consider these factors to arrive at their rulings. The determination of mental illness and its impact on an individual's capacity to understand their actions and discern right from wrong is a complex process that involves experts in psychology and psychiatry.
It is important to remember that discussions about legal decisions should be approached with respect for the justice system, the law, and the rights of individuals involved. If you have concerns about a specific case or ruling, it's essential to seek advice from legal professionals or reliable sources for a comprehensive understanding of the matter.