Responding to a question with another question is a common communication strategy used by people for various reasons. Here are some possible explanations for why some individuals answer a question with a question:
Clarification: Sometimes, the person may not fully understand the original question and may seek clarification to ensure they answer accurately. By asking a question in return, they attempt to grasp the context or specific details.
Buying time: Responding with a question can be a way to gain more time to think about their response. It allows them to formulate a thoughtful reply before providing an answer.
Deflection: In certain situations, people might feel uncomfortable or defensive about the question asked. They may respond with a question to redirect the focus or avoid giving a direct answer.
Testing intent: By asking a follow-up question, the person might be trying to discern the intent behind the original question. They might want to know if the questioner is seeking specific information or if there's an underlying motive.
Socratic method: In educational or philosophical contexts, answering a question with a question can be a teaching technique, encouraging the other person to think critically and arrive at conclusions themselves.
Politeness or social norms: In some cultures or social settings, directly answering a question without any rapport-building or context-establishing exchange might be considered abrupt or impolite. Responding with a question can be a way to engage in a more conversational manner.
Avoiding confrontation: In sensitive or contentious situations, answering directly might lead to disagreements or conflicts. Responding with a question could be an attempt to sidestep potential confrontations.
It's essential to consider the context and individual communication styles when interpreting why someone responds with a question instead of a direct answer. People's communication strategies can vary based on personality, cultural background, personal experiences, and the specific circumstances they find themselves in.